Insight · updated

In-House Marketing or Agency in 2027?

In-house marketing or agency: the five-question framework nutrition brands use to decide capability by capability, without bringing everything in-house.

In-House Marketing or Agency in 2027?

En bref — 82% of advertisers have brought part of their marketing in-house, but 92% still keep external partners, with an average of 61% of the work done in-house (ANA, 2023). The in-house versus agency debate isn’t settled wholesale: it’s decided capability by capability, based on volume, speed, proximity, scarcity and outside perspective.

In-house marketing or agency: the choice is rarely made from a blank slate. Most nutrition industry players already run some digital and creative work internally. The real question is what comes next: which capability to bring in, which to leave outside. One benchmark from the ANA (Association of National Advertisers): 82% of US advertisers had moved part of their marketing in-house by 2023, yet 92% of them still worked with external partners [1].

82% insource, 92% still pay an agency: the real split

Insourcing is no longer a trend. It’s the norm. The ANA has tracked the shift since 2008, when 42% of its members already had an in-house team doing agency-type work. That figure reached 58% in 2013, 78% in 2018, 82% in 2023 [1]. Over fifteen years, a 40-point rise, roughly 2.7 points a year.

The decisive number sits one line below. Among advertisers who have insourced, 92% still work with external agencies, and on average 61% of the work is done in-house. That leaves close to 40% still outside [1].

Large groups do the same. The WFA (World Federation of Advertisers) surveyed 45 multinationals in 2023: two-thirds have an in-house agency, and every one of them keeps working with external partners [2].

For nutrition marketing teams, the lesson is blunt. Treating the in-house marketing or agency debate as all-or-nothing is the wrong move. The useful decision gets made capability by capability, and it gets revisited as volume and tools change.

No public study to date gives a reliable insourcing rate specific to ingredient suppliers or B2B nutrition. The 2026 Smartcore/Informa Markets report, based on 282 respondents from the sector, mostly flags a capacity problem: 49% of suppliers name a lack of resources or staff as their top barrier [13].

On the BDB side, among 51 marketing decision-makers of whom 78% are ingredient manufacturers, 49% struggle to find a partner combining sector expertise with creative excellence, and 59% struggle to build a differentiated message [14]. The ANA and WFA figures above stay cross-sector: they show the trend, not the specifics of this particular field.

The invoice decides first, the actual need decides second

The first capability brought in-house is usually media or development. The reason is budget visibility: these are the most visible line items on the external invoice, so they’re the ones where savings get calculated fastest.

WFA data confirms the reflex. Among the multinationals surveyed, the top motivation for insourcing is cost, cited by 83% of respondents [2], ahead of speed (76%) and control over brand consistency, cited by two-thirds. On the ANA side, the work most often pulled back in-house is digital creative (social, search, email) and media [1].

The reasoning holds, but it has a blind spot. It picks the capability based on the invoice, not the need. Bringing execution back in-house doesn’t automatically bring back what came with it: perspective, fresh ideas, comparison with other brands and other sectors.

One signal says the criterion is changing. Between 2018 and 2023, the share of US advertisers judging their in-house team on cost savings dropped from 69% to 62%, while those judging it on business performance rose from 45% to 59% [1]. The yardstick is moving from cost towards added value. For settling in-house marketing or agency, that shift matters as much as the size of the invoices.

Speed isn’t won by changing the address of whoever produces the work

The second driver of insourcing beats cost: speed. Digital demands fluidity, yet the classic chain with an external partner is long. Brief, feedback, revision, production, publication. Each step adds delay, and a 2026 WFA survey of 45 multinationals puts the average brief-to-publication cycle at 11 days when an external partner is involved.

Advertisers say so themselves. In the WFA study, faster processes are the second motivation for insourcing, cited by 76% of the multinationals surveyed, and nearly one in two (47%) judges its in-house team on speed to market [2].

Bringing a capability in-house doesn’t shorten the chain on its own, though. One WFA member advertiser put it plainly: AI can generate an image in three minutes, but if legal sign-off takes a week, you still lose a week [3].

You win speed by removing back-and-forth, not by moving the producer’s desk. An in-house team waiting on three rounds of sign-off won’t move any faster than an agency. Whatever has to ship same-day belongs with you, as long as you also shorten the approval chain.

Five questions settle in-house marketing or agency, role by role

Instead of settling the in-house marketing or agency question once and for all, run each capability through five questions. The framework forces the discussion role by role, rather than a debate on principle.

CriterionQuestion to askWhat it reveals
VolumeNeeded every week, or just a few days a month?Below a certain threshold, a full-time role isn’t justified.
SpeedSame-day turnaround needed, or is a brief-and-wait cycle acceptable?Anything that runs on the news cycle copes poorly with intermediaries.
ProximityDoes it touch customer data or the brand itself?The closer it sits, the riskier it is to leave outside.
ScarcityCan you recruit this profile, and keep them?An isolated specialist has neither peers nor perspective.
Outside perspectiveDoes the capability wear thin from seeing only one brand?If so, it needs fresh air from elsewhere.

Applied to the most common capabilities, the framework produces three zones. Keep in-house: project management, data and measurement (the capability closest to the customer), recurring production. Share: media and development, with oversight and access kept in-house. Source outside: strategy and creative, on a part-time basis, wherever volume is low and outside perspective is worth the most.

This classification is far from universal. A nutrition brand whose website is the product won’t file development in the same box as an ingredient processor. Hybrid models already exist: among the multinationals surveyed by the WFA, 28% embed agency teams inside their in-house structure and 24% rely on a freelancer pool [2].

AI doesn’t fix inbreeding, it accelerates it

An in-house team sees one brand, every day. By comparing itself only to itself, it goes round in circles. The risk has a name in the research: creative stagnation, the top threat cited for in-house teams in the ANA’s 2026 report, ahead of talent burnout [4]. The problem isn’t new. Back in 2019, 63% of US advertisers already said they struggled to keep in-house talent engaged [5]. And AI can make it worse: trained on your own content, it reproduces your own habits. The risk doesn’t disappear, it gets automated.

What AI shifts in the framework, and what it leaves untouched

AI speeds up production. It doesn’t tell you what to produce, and it doesn’t shorten approvals. Kimberly-Clark says its content creation time fell from 24 days to two hours on an in-house AI platform [6]. Two cases from the ingredients world point the same way. At Givaudan, the in-house platform Ooby, used daily by more than 70% of marketers, generates dozens of concept ideas within minutes [13]. At Kerry, the KerryKalaido tool produces a concept (name, flavour direction, sales pitch) in 30 seconds, against an ideation process that used to take hours, days or weeks [15]. In both cases, no published data quantifies a reduced agency budget or an eliminated role: the acceleration hits ideation, not approval or full-scale launch. Inside the framework, the volume threshold for production collapses. A small, well-equipped team can now produce what used to need a large one.

This effect stays concentrated on execution. In the ANA’s 2026 report, 49% of respondents say AI lets them do more work without cutting their external spend, and only 19% say it lets them produce what they previously outsourced to an agency [4]. The mediasense-WFA study points the same way: every in-house team surveyed produces faster thanks to AI, but strategic uses stay underexploited [3].

External partners feel it too. In B2B, the share of marketers planning to raise their digital marketing agency budget dropped from 51% to 31% in a single year, a 20-point fall, yet 93% still use agencies [7].

For your in-house marketing or agency decisions in nutrition, the line is clear: AI shifts volume and speed, not outside perspective. Production moves in-house faster, but the need to be challenged from the outside stays just as strong.

34% move work in-house, 7% move it back out: insourcing reverses too

The decision to insource is reversible, and some advertisers have proven it. Intel shut down the creative and production activities of its Agency Inside in 2018 to move closer to its external agencies [8]. In May 2025, Keurig Dr Pepper closed its in-house agency, Liquid Sunshine, in favour of external partners [9]. The following month, Expedia scaled back its own [10].

Even established models shift. Jaguar Land Rover, which set up Spark44 back in 2011, brought in Accenture as a partner, then launched a global review of its creative agencies in 2025 [11]. As early as 2018, companies reversing course cited two reasons: trouble recruiting and retaining the right talent, and in-house tools that proved harder to maintain than expected [12].

These cases stay a minority. In the ANA’s 2026 report, 34% of respondents see work shifting from external to in-house, against 7% the other way round [4]. The balance moves both ways.

For your marketing and procurement teams, three questions are worth more than any benchmark. Which capability is slowing you down the most right now: that’s often the one to pull closer, ahead of the one costing the most in invoices.

Who on your team knows how to brief and challenge an external partner: without that pilot, neither the in-house team nor the agency will perform at its best. And what will stop you going round in circles two years from now: if the answer is “nothing”, an outside perspective is missing somewhere. Which role on your current team did you bring in-house for its cost, and which for its value?

References

  1. ANA. The Continued Rise of the In-House Agency: 2023 Edition. Association of National Advertisers. 2023. 162 respondents, United States.
  2. WFA and The Observatory International. In-housing study, 45 multinationals. World Federation of Advertisers. 2023.
  3. mediasense and WFA. In-Housing AI. More than 30 global companies. 2025.
  4. ANA. State of In-Housing. Association of National Advertisers. 2026. 404 In-House Excellence Awards judges.
  5. ANA, BCG and Reed Smith. Managing In-House Agency Creative. 111 ANA members. 2019.
  6. Reuters via Marketing Tech News. AI is moving more ad production in-house. 2026.
  7. Forrester. As AI Use Expands, B2B Marketers Become More Selective About Agency Spend. 2026.
  8. Adweek. Intel to shutter in-house Agency Inside creative and production operations. 2018.
  9. Adweek. BBH wins 7UP and RC Cola after Keurig Dr Pepper shuts in-house shop. 2025.
  10. Ad Age. Expedia is downsizing its in-house agency. 2025.
  11. Storyboard18. Jaguar Land Rover launches global creative agency review. 2025.
  12. Digiday. Some companies backtrack on taking marketing in-house. 2018.
  13. Smartcore / Informa Markets. B2B Food and Nutrition Marketing Report 2026. 282 respondents, food/beverage/nutraceutical sector. 2026.
  14. BDB Global. The 2025 B2B Marketing Benchmark: Food & Nutrition. 51 marketing decision-makers, 78% ingredient manufacturers. 2025.
  15. Enterprise Ireland. Case Study: Kerry Group, KerryKalaido. 1 October 2026.
  16. Givaudan. 2025 Integrated Report, AI-powered Ooby.

FAQ

Should you bring all marketing R&D in-house, or keep an agency?

Neither, wholesale. According to the ANA (2023), 92% of advertisers who have brought work in-house still keep external partners, with an average of 61% of the work done in-house. The decision is made capability by capability, not all at once.

What’s the number one reason for bringing a capability in-house?

Cost, cited by 83% of the multinationals surveyed by the WFA (2023), followed by execution speed (76%). But the criterion is shifting towards value: at ANA member companies, evaluation based on business performance rose from 45% in 2018 to 59% in 2023.

Can AI replace an external agency?

Partially. In the ANA’s 2026 report, only 19% of respondents say AI lets them produce what they used to outsource to an agency, versus 49% who say they’re simply doing more work without reducing their external spend. AI shifts volume and speed, not outside perspective.

Which capabilities should be kept in-house as a priority?

Project management, data and measurement (the closest to the customer), and high-volume recurring production. Media and development tend to be shared, with oversight kept in-house. Strategy and creative are more often sourced externally, on a part-time basis.

What is creative stagnation in an in-house team?

It’s the effect of seeing only one brand day in, day out: the team goes round in circles for lack of outside comparison. It’s the top threat cited for in-house teams in the ANA’s 2026 report, ahead of talent burnout. AI trained on your own content can make it worse.

Can you reverse course after bringing work in-house?

Yes, and documented cases exist: Intel (2018), Keurig Dr Pepper and Expedia (2025) closed or scaled back their in-house agencies. In the ANA’s 2026 report, 34% of respondents see work shifting from external to in-house, and 7% the other way round. The balance is reviewed every year.